Sunday, March 16, 2008

The Geoff Millard Story at WSI

During the panel on Racism, IVAW member Geoff Millard repeated a story he has been telling for some time, but with a difference. Millard finally named names of two of the officers involved. More on that later. Last July the story was reported at Common Dreams as:
During the summer of 2005, Sergeant Millard, who served as an assistant to a general in Tikrit, attended a briefing on a checkpoint shooting, at which his role was to flip PowerPoint slides.

“This unit sets up this traffic control point, and this 18-year-old kid is on top of an armored Humvee with a .50-caliber machine gun,” he said. “This car speeds at him pretty quick and he makes a split-second decision that that’s a suicide bomber, and he presses the butterfly trigger and puts 200 rounds in less than a minute into this vehicle. It killed the mother, a father and two kids. The boy was aged 4 and the daughter was aged 3. And they briefed this to the general. And they briefed it gruesome. I mean, they had pictures. They briefed it to him. And this colonel turns around to this full division staff and says, ‘If these fucking hajis learned to drive, this shit wouldn’t happen.’”
The audio from WSI repeats the story, although it omits the 18 year age and adds the names of the general and colonel. Eight seconds of Millard's testimony in which he quoted the colonel about "hajis" has also been erased from the War Comes Home audio. However, Veterans for Peace reported it as others heard it on the live broadcast and recorded it.

Last July, SFC Jeff Nuding, who is proprietor of Dadmanly milblog, wrote a deconstruction of Millard's story based upon it being written in The Nation, that is more than worth the read:

I can’t dismiss the anti-war voices in The Nation piece, but I can quickly surmise that many of the soldiers interviewed are anti-war careerists, who have attached themselves to groups like Code Pink or Iraqi Veterans Against the War (IVAW). I can also state with absolute conviction that among those who make the most damning assertions about US military conduct have no first hand basis for their assertions.

Sergeant Geoffrey Millard is one such soldier who makes claims beyond his experience in The Nation piece. Millard was assigned to the Rear Operations Center (ROC), 42nd Infantry Division at Forward Operating Base (FOB) Speicher in Tikrit. I also served with the 42nd, I am familiar with the ROC at Speicher, and know two officers who served in the ROC during the same period as Millard, one of whom I would say I have a casual acquaintance (and great respect). I served as his First Sergeant for a brief period when he was the HHC Commander.

After redeployment, I had a chance to get reacquainted with spent some time explaining to me what his section did, how they interacted with the Division HQ and the other 42nd ID Commands. Among other duties, the ROC tracked the convoys that exited and/or entered the FOB. Their mission included the tracking of IEDs and VBIEDs in the Area of Operations, supervising the proper submission and quality control of convoy paperwork – there’s always paperwork for everything -- and keeping command and staff informed of recent trends, updated threat assessments, and so forth. SGT Millard served as a staff NCO in an administrative section in the rear – what combat soldiers would correctly (if harshly) ridicule as a “Fobbit.” (I was a Fobbit too, though I complete about a dozen convoys off the FOB.)

In The Nation piece, Millard even reinforces the obvious distance from which he offers criticism of our military, as the “clicker” for a Command Powerpoint presentation on an unfortunate checkpoint shooting of a family. His beef in that instance? That a Colonel, briefing staff officers and commanders at what sounds to be like a weekly Commander’s brief, made the comment that “If these fucking hajis learned to drive, this shit wouldn’t happen.”

If that passes for scandal to anti-war types, we’ve come quite a ways from My Li.

Based on what I know of the 42nd in Tikrit and our Command structure, the Colonel Millard uses as example for US military callousness is likely a Brigade Commander, most probably from Artillery or one of the Infantry Brigades. These were some no sh**, can the nicety type commanders. But discipline is discipline, they knew the public relations and “hearts and minds” importance of their missions, and took extraordinary effort to prevent the kinds of unfortunately incident briefed in Millard’s powerpoint slides. The fact itself that they briefed the incident in detail speaks volumes about how important the command viewed these setbacks, as setbacks, to be avoided however possible.

What Millard didn’t add to this little anecdote was what happened next, based on this incident and others like it in theater: revised Rules of Engagement, follow-up training and briefings by Commanders and NCOs, and changes in procedures for Convoy drivers, truck commanders (TCs), and gunners. I know, because our guys bitched like hell every time some incident or another caused yet another command directive: Wave them off (or for a while, throw small stones at windshields), point the barrel of the M2 at them, and lastly, fire a warning shot on the pavement in front of the vehicle.

Sometimes that meant the round glanced back into the engine block, disabling the vehicle entirely – not good, now you have a broken down vehicle in your way – or even into the vehicle and causing injuries to driver or passengers.

Iraqi drivers obey a coda of traffic laws known only unto themselves, if at all, in peacetime. Adding the stresses and threats of insurgents, VBIEDS, US and Coalition Military, Iraqi Army, and Iraqi Police into the mix, they only get worse. So yes, for local commanders, if the locals would exercise a little more care and prudence, Commanders at all levels wouldn’t have any such incidents for which soldier correction would be required.

Just as at our FOB (Danger) down the road about 20 kilometers, FOB Speicher received its share of mortar and rocket attacks, the overwhelming majority of which were completely ineffective without causing any injuries. Yet SGT Millard, endearing himself to his anti-war audiences, makes it out like some Vietnam redux, only worse, with “pops of machine gun fire and the bangs of mortar rounds exploding all hours of the day and night.”

Our FOB was tiny in comparison to the square mileage of Speicher, so the net effect of any rounds impacting this great big patch of desert with great amounts of open space had to be even less intimidating.

Look, we had soldiers who were spooked by what little we experienced at Danger. I wouldn’t dream of suggesting poor Millard can’t be suffering from post traumatic stress syndrome (PTSD) -- if not from close physical contact with Cindy Sheehan, then from whatever he witnessed at Speicher (or was told about, or heard about in FOB gossip). But I would bet a month’s wages that, pressed top back up his claims, Millard like most of the other voices The Nation selected, they “heard about this kind of sh** from lots of guys.” (Especially after making themselves celebrities in the anti-war industry.)


Read it all.

For an interesting on-line discussion between Sgt Geoff Millard and a SFC Holmes who served with him, go here and scroll down.

14 comments:

Jeff said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Denis Keohane said...

Got it, Jeff, and deleted your e-mail addie.

rongkirby said...

I tried to use your link to the Gathering of Eagles Video but the You Tube link indicated the GOE video was removed. However the GOE video is still on You Tube at
http://youtube.com/watch?v=kBe8Yj4QAAQ

rongkirby said...

Thank you for shining the light on GM. Unlike Winter Soldier 1 when the lies told by John Kerry and his bunch were not found out for years, many are scrutinizing these IVAW's stories in hours by researchers and troops that served with them. You might add Eaglesup.us March down Constitution Avenue, DC in response to WS ll to your web links.

GEORGE SAMEK CW-3 US ARMY RETIRED said...

As a two tour Vietnam Vet & retired US Army CW-3 I joined with a team from the Gathering of Eagles on March 13 2008 to speak with Congress concerning the WS #2 & the need to end there ploy to smear each of you new vets from the war on terror. Fight them now or live with there lies for the rest of your life.
The Gathering of Eagles will fight with you.

The time to fight is now. we fight for our honored dead from the Vietnam War. you must do the same for yours.
Our GOE flag bears the words Never Again..We are talking about your generation of combat vets. You are our Grand Children,., when they attack you we will stand with you.
Stand your ground, we are behind you 24/7 365

Make these people stand up under oath. make them bring facts. If they do enter there lies into the Congressional record I assure you a rebuttal will be entered right behind it.
To the IVAW I say..Put your facts & proof on the table. you will never reclaim your lost honor by attempting to steal the honor of better men then you.

Denis Keohane said...

Thanks, rongkirby, and will re-link!

wsi said...

small note about millard:
millard is from New York, Geoff Millard joined the NY Army National guard in1998 at the age of 17. He served for 9 years including tours of duty at ground zero after 9-11 and for 13 months in Operation Iraqi Freedom.

alot of people mention he has been "dehumanized" but He has not necessarilly been dehumanized, Millard will testify on endemic racism during his tour of Iraq, including among high-ranking Army officers.

Cheers,
Chrissy

_________________________________
wsi marketing

Stolen Valor Buster said...

And if anyone wants to see a picture of Stolen Valor Geoff Millard wearing a Combat Infantryman's Badge (CIB), an award he did not earn, on his DCU top, goto:
www.peaceandjustice.it/images/cc2/34.jpg

It's bad enough that this spotlight and camera hog is being a war profiteer by charging groups to have him speak, but he also goes out and wears awards he didn't earn.
So much for integrity.

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!

Anonymous said...

Buy [url=http://buy-cialis.icr38.net/Gasex]gasex online[/url] easy - Colossal Offer valium online now - Incredible Offer

Anonymous said...

[... ] is one another relavant source of information on this topic[...]
http://homeinsurance.cheap-quotes.info/

Anonymous said...

Q5qufW6Ps9 Resort Casino kUE7fdv4I Choctaw Casino El6CuaAUqz Casino Gambling Do91xlzOtY Winstar Casino jbYE9K3Wnm Station Casinos OVqX5EYKT Casion feHZEnjdtz Indian Casino coiEbdwzr Morongo Casino

Anonymous said...

Decent submit! Will you follow up on this incredible matter?

Anonymous said...

I really liked your article.